7 Best Polyurethane for Wood Countertops (Updated List)

Finding the best polyurethane for wood countertops can be tricky. After testing seven popular products, one stood out from the rest.

AFM Safecoat Acrylacq Wood Sealer impressed us with its unmatched performance and results. It’s durable, easy to use, and enhances the natural beauty of wood.

If you’re looking to protect your countertops while keeping them stunning, this guide will help you choose the right product for your needs.

Keep reading to see why Safecoat is the top choice and discover other great options.

Our Top Picks

Best Polyurethane for Wood Countertops

1. AFM Safecoat Acrylacq Wood Sealer – Best overall for countertops
2. Minwax Fast-Drying Polyurethane – Best bang for the buck
3. General Finishes High Topcoat – Best durable coat for butcher block countertops
4. Rust-Oleum Watco Butcher Block – Best food-safe formulation
5. Minwax Helmsman Spar Urethane – Most versatile polyurethane finish
6. Varathane Ultimate Poly – Best water-based polyurethane for countertops
7. Rust-Oleum Triple Thick Polyurethane – Best one-coat coverage

Best Polyurethane for Wood Countertops: Product Reviews

The polyurethane marketplace is flooded with various brands and formulations. 

1. Best Overall for Countertops – AFM Safecoat Acrylacq Wood Sealer

If you worry about stains or scratches on your wood countertop, try AFM Safecoat Acrylacq, our best overall stainer for countertops.

It protects your countertop from daily wear, including scratches and stains. It is also resistant to common household chemicals and UV rays.

This means your countertop stays safe from sunlight fading and damage from chemical spills. The glossy finish makes it easier to clean and maintain.

It resists scratches better, keeping your countertop looking great for longer. Its high gloss sheen can make any wood surface look spectacular.

If your kitchen is small, this finish can make it appear bigger. It reflects light, brightening dark spaces and making them more livable.

While it is the most expensive option, you will get the best results with it.

What We Liked Most

The product has a non-toxic, water-based formula. 
It dries pretty fast, which can save you time to move on to other things sooner. 
The polyurethane guarantees superior quality coats on your wooden countertops. 
This poly is low-odor, making it safe for people with allergies or smell sensitivities. 

What Could Be Improved

Dirt and dust may be more easily visible on the glossy countertop. 
The water-based formula may require multiple coats to achieve the desired coverage.
It is quite pricy

---

2. Best Bang for the Buck – Minwax Fast-Drying Polyurethane

Minwax Fast-Drying Polyurethane is a trusted brand in the US. It is perfect for protecting and enhancing wood countertops.

Its quick drying time is a big advantage for woodworking projects.

I use it for both new projects and refinishing old woodwork. It saves me time without sacrificing quality.

Once applied, it gives a beautiful satin sheen. This finish highlights the natural beauty of the wood. The result is smooth, luxurious, and stunning.

It is also very durable. It protects surfaces well and keeps them looking great for longer. For its price, Minwax offers excellent value.

Despite its affordability, it delivers exceptional value and impressive results. The quick drying time, durability, and elegant finish make it a smart investment.

Minwax Fast-Drying Polyurethane is a must-have for woodworkers at any level.

What We Liked Most

The satin sheen brings out the natural beauty of the wood.
The polyurethane is durable and offers lasting protection to wooden countertops. 
Minwax is a leading brand with a good reputation for creating dependable products. 
This product dries relatively quickly than many other oil-based products.
Trusted brand in the US

What Could Be Improved

Limited availability of color options (clear finish only).

---

3. Best Durable Coat for Countertops – General Finishes High Performance Topcoat

In my experience, General Finishes High-Performance Topcoat is an invaluable addition to the toolkit of any DIY enthusiast or woodworker. Its primary purpose is to provide top-tier protective finishes, especially for countertops.

One of the top-selling points of this topcoat is its exceptional durability. It ranks among the toughest consumer polyurethane topcoats, providing a robust shield against scratches and wear. This ensures that your finished projects can withstand the test of time.

Another stand out feature is its unique ability to resist yellowing, a common concern when applying clear topcoats over bright white or light-coloured paints. However, it’s worth noting that while this topcoat does an excellent job in minimizing the risk of yellowing, there may still be some degree of yellowing, depending on the substrate.

During my hands-on testing, I found the rapid drying time to be the most impressive feature. With a mere 1 to 2 hours needed between coats, it significantly speeds up project timelines, achieving a flawless finish in record time.

While General Finishes High-Performance Topcoat may not be the absolute fastest-drying option available, its remarkable resistance to yellowing, swift drying time, and unmatched durability make it a strong choice if you prioritize long-lasting quality and the longevity of your projects. It deserves its place as the second choice in the reviews.

What We Liked Most

Unique ability to resist yellowing.
Rapid drying time of 1 to 2 hours between coats.
Exceptional durability and scratch resistance.
Versatility across various surfaces, including wood furniture and cabinetry.

What Could Be Improved

This poly is formulated exclusively for interior use, so you cannot use any leftover product on your outdoor projects. 
Some degree of yellowing may still occur.

---

4. Best Food-Safe Formulation – Rust Oleum Watco Butcher Block

Rust-Oleum polyurethane is a fantastic choice, especially when prioritising food safety in your woodworking projects. It’s explicitly formulated to be food-safe, focusing on cutting boards, salad bowls, butcher blocks, and kitchen countertops.

What sets this product apart, in my experience, is its complete non-toxicity, which makes it ideal for wooden kitchen countertops without any concerns. Its fast drying time is another plus, drying to the touch in under two hours. This allows for multiple recoats daily, making project completion much more efficient.

Even better, the polyurethane surface becomes usable in just 72 hours. However, I’d recommend checking the cure time and allowing it to fully cure before using the countertop for any food-related tasks.

Once the surface has fully cured, it’s perfectly safe for food contact, and you can use it for any kitchen role without any health worries.

I’ve also found it to be beginner-friendly. Its self-levelling property ensures a smooth application process, even for those new to DIY projects. No need to fret about brush marks; they don’t appear on your project, giving you a professional-looking finish with ease.

What We Liked Most

It is formulated to be safe for food contact.
This polyurethane is easy to apply. You can use a clean cloth to wipe it onto your wood countertop. 
It dries to form a rich sheen that helps enhance the wood on your kitchen counter.
The lustrous sheen is easy to maintain 

What Could Be Improved

Some users find it pretty sticky while applying it. It is therefore recommended to wear gloves when applying it. 
You may easily confuse dry surface to be cured.

---

5. Best Versatile Polyurethane Finish for Kitchen Countertops – Minwax Helmsman Water-Based Spar Urethane

Helmsman spar urethane is one of the very best clear coats on the market. It is formulated to work both indoors and outdoors across various surfaces.

Its superior ability to adhere to virtually any surface makes it a go-to polyurethane for tabletops and kitchen countertops. There is no need to worry about being stuck with leftover poly.

You can use what is left on any other project regardless of where it is located. If you love the natural color of your wood, this polyurethane from Minwax may be ideal for you.

Thanks to its special water-based formula, it goes on clear and stays clear. The clear color does an excellent job of preserving your wood’s natural color for the long haul.

It is a non-yellowing polyurethane, so you can depend on the super-tough coat to remain crystal clear for ages. The superior UV blockers in this product help keep it from breaking under the sun.

So you may want to consider it if you have a spacious kitchen with lots of sunlight coming in. It will do a great job of preventing your wooden countertop from fading.

What We Liked Most

This polyurethane offers dependable protection throughout the year. It is formulated to be flexible enough to withstand extreme weather changes. 
It is extremely versatile and can work on many surfaces, so whatever remains after finishing your kitchen countertop will not go to waste. 
The water-based formula means it is low-odor and non-toxic
It dries to form a beautiful satin finish 

What Could Be Improved

Some users find the finish to be rather glossy and not satin as they expect. This is likely a result of not mixing the product well before applying it to the project.

---

6. Best Water-Based polyurethane for Countertops – Varathane Ultimate Polyurethane

As the name suggests, this water-based polyurethane offers the ultimate coverage and protection for your wood countertop. It is specially formulated to dry to the touch in just 30 minutes, the fastest any polyurethane product can ever dry. 

Such drying speeds can be a godsend, especially if you are pressed for time and must proceed to other things. With this product, you will be able to recoat as many times as necessary and complete the project in just a few hours. 

Just one gallon is enough to cover up to 125 square feet. This high coverage means you can use less product to complete a large project. Eventually, you spend less money on your project.

Since this product is water-based, it emits less odor than most wood finishes. This property makes it ideal, especially for someone with smell sensitivities or allergies. 

The water-based formula also guarantees a clear color that remains as such over time. If you love your wood in its beautiful natural color, you can count on this product to help preserve that color.

What We Liked Most

It forms a durable coat that protects the wooden surface for ages. 
The product is non-yellowing
It allows for easy cleanup with dishwashing liquid or detergent and water.  
The protective coat is scratch-resistant
The satin finish of this poly helps preserve the wood’s natural appearance

What Could Be Improved

The product goes on thin, so you may have to apply several thin coats to achieve the desired coverage. 

---

7. Best One-Coat Coverage – Rust-Oleum Triple Thick Polyurethane

If you are not a fan of recoating, this triple-thick polyurethane from Rust-Oleum may be your best choice. Its one-coat coverage means that a single coat is all you need to offer the coverage of three standard coats.

That is the greatest coverage we have seen on any poly. And you will be happy to know that the product adheres to all interior wood surfaces, so if some of it remains after completing your countertop, it will not go to waste.

You can use it on a door, furniture, trim, etc. The special formula forms a robust coat that protects the countertop excellently against scratches and stains.

The product is fast drying. Despite offering the coverage of three coats in one, it will be completely dry to the touch in two hours. 

The self-leveling formula of this polyurethane helps eliminate brush marks. As a result, you can easily achieve professional-looking results with this product even if you are unskilled in using such wood finishes.

What We Liked Most

This product offers the best durability, with each coat providing coverage equivalent to three coats of standard polys. This helps guarantee lasting protection. 
It is fast-drying despite being high coverage. 
It forms a matte finish that can hide surface imperfections much better. 
The one-coat coverage can be labor-saving, reducing the number of recoats needed. 

What Could Be Improved

This product is meant exclusively for indoor use. However, if you have some outdoor wood to protect with polyurethane, you have no luck with this Rust-Oleum Triple Thick Poly. 

---

Best Polyurethane for Wood Countertops Comparison Table

Is Polyurethane Food Safe for Wood Countertops?

Yes, poly is food-safe and suitable for wooden kitchen countertops. However, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) notes that the finished surface must be allowed to dry and cure fully before being considered food-safe polyurethane. 

This cure time varies from one poly to the other, so you need to read the label for the manufacturer’s recommended drying and curing times. This will help ensure you are using the product safely. 

Using a polyurethane surface for food handling before it is fully cured can be risky. The product may release chemical fumes and odors that can cause negative symptoms when used before fully cured.

Types of Polyurethane for Countertops 

The two main types of polyurethane available on countertops are oil-based and water-based poly. Each type has distinctive characteristics that make it a better choice than the other.

Understanding these characteristics can help you choose better for your project.  

i. Oil-based poly 

This type of liquid coating contains solvents that can be highly flammable, so the product requires careful handling away from flame-causing agents.

The solvents also give oil-based poly a higher toxicity profile, so you must wear a protective mask or respirator when handling it.

The product can emit toxic fumes for several weeks after application. Therefore, paying careful attention to the cure time is recommended to decide when to use the polyurethane surface correctly. 

On the brighter side, oil-based poly can be highly durable and resistant to scratches. Even though different sheen levels are available, the product also dries to form a glossy finish. 

You must use solvents like mineral spirits or turpentine to clean oil-based poly. This may be challenging for people who do not keep such solvents at home.

Also, read our article “Is oil-based polyurethane” to gain a deeper understanding of its water-resistant properties and applications.

ii. Water-Based Polyurethane  

This type of poly consists of water instead of toxic solvents are the base. This use of water makes water-based poly safer, with low toxicity levels. 

This polyurethane dries faster, so you can expect shorter curing times than oil-based poly. The poly also cleans up easily with mere soap and water, making it stress-free to use.

Water-based poly has very low volatile organic compound (VOCs) levels in its profile, so you may apply it to your countertop without wearing any special breathing equipment. 

Most water-based polyurethanes will also go on clear and stay clear over time. This is as opposed to oil-based polyurethane, that might turn amber with time. Some oil-based polyurethanes also carry a yellowish tint. 

On the flipside, water-based poly may be less durable and not hold up well to heat. Nonetheless, this type of poly remains the better choice for most indoor applications. 

What to Consider When Selecting Polyurethane for Countertops 

Knowing what to look for in any product can help you choose better. So this section helps you with choosing a polyurethane finish for your wood countertop. 

Sheen level

Polyurethane can be high-gloss, semi-gloss, satin, or matte. High gloss finishes reflect the most light, while matte and satin polyurethane finishes reflect the least light. 

So if you have a small kitchen, you might be better off with a relatively glossy finish that will help make the space look brighter by reflecting more light.

Food safety

Kitchen counters are often used for food preparation. This means the product you use to coat that surface must be safe for food contact. Otherwise, you could be looking at potential food poisoning issues. 

That said, you should also look for a safe countertop for pets and people, such as maple.

Durability 

This is a no-brainer. Not all polyurethane brands will give you the same service life, so you want to go for the one that will last the longest on your countertop. Such a product gives you the biggest bang for your buck and saves you money in the long run. 

Eco-friendliness

Oil or solvent-based polyurethanes consist of chemical solvents that emit potentially toxic fumes throughout their curing periods. Such volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from these products generally harm the environment.

On the other hand, water-based finishes tend to be low-VOC, making them friendlier to the environment. So you may want to go for these safer alternatives whenever that option is viable. 

Drying time

No one wants to take several days on one project when they could complete it sooner. While some polyurethanes dry to the touch in 30 minutes, others can take anywhere from 4 to 6 hours to dry to the touch. 

The product that dries to the touch in half an hour will allow you to recoat in about two hours, meaning you can complete the entire project in just a couple of hours within the day. 

In contrast, the product that takes up to six hours to dry to the touch may need eight hours to be ready for recoating.

Therefore, when using such a product, you may be unable to complete the project in less than three days, which can be inconvenient. 

So it makes sense to go for a fast-drying poly whenever possible to finish your projects sooner. 

Related read: How to choose a polyurethane finish for hardwood floors.

Sealing Butcher Block Countertops with Polyurethane

Step1: Assemble the supplies you’ll need and prepare the workspace. 

Step2: Sand the wood countertop along the wood grain to remove any blemishes such as heat rings and make it smooth. 

Step 3: Wipe the sanding dust with a tack cloth and let the wood dry completely before applying polyurethane. (Find out how to remove bubbles from dried polyurethane)

Step 4: Seal the wood with thinned poly. To make the thinned poly, use a glass jar to mix oil-based poly with mineral spirits in the ratio of 2:1 or water-based poly with water in the same ratio. Stir the mixture gently with a stick, taking care not to disturb or shake it to introduce bubbles. Then apply with a brush. 

Step 5: After the sealer has dried completely, apply polyurethane to the wood with natural bristles (when applying oil-based polyurethane) and synthetic bristles (for water-based poly).

Step 6: Wet sanding the polyurethane and applying additional coats of the product as directed on the label. 

Best Polyurethane for Wood Countertops: FAQs

Best Polyurethane for Countertops: Conclusion 

Polyurethane varnish is ideal for sealing wood countertops because it forms a tough layer that can significantly protect the wood surface from scratches, water damage, and UV radiation.

However, it is essential to choose the best product for your project. We hope these reviews and detailed user guides help make your next project successful.

What next? Read our article on epoxy versus polyurethane to know more about these finishes.